The short answer
A roofer is worth walking away from if there is no written quote, cash is the only payment accepted, you are pressed to sign on the doorstep, no business details are given, or the Building Regulations route is brushed aside. One of these is a warning; two or more is a reason to stop.
Six warning signs at the quote stage
Most problems start before any tile is touched, at the point where a price and a contract are agreed. Look for these:
- No written quote: a price given aloud, or a figure scribbled on a card, leaves you nothing to hold the firm to.
- Cash only: a refusal to take any traceable payment leaves no record of what you paid.
- Pressure to sign today: an offer that vanishes if you wait is a reason to wait.
- No business details: a missing name, address or landline, or a mobile number alone, makes a complaint hard to deliver.
- No look at the roof: a price named from the pavement, before anyone has been up or checked the loft, is a guess.
- Vague on regulations: a roofer who waves away Building Regulations without naming the route has not thought about them.
A sound quote is the reverse of this list. It comes after a survey, it names the work, and it gives one written total price,. The Daylight Roofing home page shows what that looks like, and the page on choosing a roofer sets out what to ask before anyone starts. Write the questions down and ask every firm the same ones; a firm that is straightforward answers them without fuss.
Doorstep selling and the cooling-off right
A caller who knocks and says loose tiles or moss were spotted from the road is selling, not surveying. You are free to say no, and free to get two or three other written quotes before deciding on anything.
Contracts signed at home carry a 14-day cancellation window under the Consumer Contracts Regulations, with a carve-out for urgent repairs that you ask a firm to attend. Anyone who says the window does not exist, or asks you to waive it, is wrong about the law. The Citizens Advice consumer helpline on 0808 223 1133 can confirm where you stand before you sign, so ring first rather than afterwards.
Having a sentence ready makes saying no easier: "Please send the quote in writing and I will decide after I have compared it." A genuine firm accepts that. A firm that turns sour, drops the price by half the moment you hesitate, or says the offer ends tonight has told you something about how the rest of the job may go. Photograph any leaflet or card you are handed, and write down when the visit took place.
Rules a dodgy roofer may skip
Some of what is missing never appears on a quote, so ask about it directly. The Planning Portal says: "In most situations, this work will need Building Regulations approval." A full re-roof goes past its 50 per cent roof limit, whatever the covering. Ask which building control route the roofer will use: the council's building control team or a registered building control approver.
| Ask about | A clear answer names |
|---|---|
| Building Regulations | The building control route |
| Scaffold on a road or pavement | A scaffold licence from the highway authority |
| Old asbestos cement sheets | Careful removal, never breaking them up |
| Price | One written total |
Poles that stand over the footway or carriageway need a scaffold licence from the highway authority; we arrange the licence with our scaffolder, and a roofer should be ready to name who deals with it. HSE's advice is to assume asbestos is there if the building was built or refurbished before 2000, so a roofer who offers to smash and skip old sheeting without a word about it is not following that advice. Compare the answers with what drives roofing costs before you commit.

