01 Matching what is already there
On an older or listed house, a repair is judged by what it does to the look of the building. A like-for-like repair uses the same material, in the same size and pattern, laid the same way. Before any quote, the existing covering is studied: its colour, its texture, the width of the courses, the shape of the ridge and hips. Salvaged pieces from a stripped slope can be used on the visible elevation, and new ones placed on a slope that cannot be seen from the road.
Listed building consent applies to works "in any manner which would affect its character as a building of special architectural or historic interest". Even a repair that looks the same may still affect character if it changes the fixing method or the texture. That is a judgement for the council, and a photograph of the present roof, taken square on with the whole slope in frame, is a useful thing to have in hand when the question is asked.

