The short answer
Yes, where the remaining covering is in good order. A section can be re-covered or repaired without touching the remainder. Under the Planning Portal's guide, re-roofing does not normally need a building regulations application if it affects less than 25 per cent of the building envelope and less than 50 per cent of the roof.
When one slope can be repaired alone
A roof is a set of slopes, and each slope can fail separately. A storm can strip tiles from one side, a leaking valley can rot the battens beneath it, and a chimney's flashing can fail while the rest of the roof is fine. In each case the damaged area can be opened up, repaired and closed again without disturbing the slopes that are in good order. A second slope that looks identical from the ground may be perfectly healthy, so repairing one side is not a half-measure; it is the right size of job.
What decides whether a partial repair is sensible is the condition of the surrounding covering, and not the size of the hole. If the tiles around the damage are sound, firmly fixed and sitting on healthy battens, the repair is local. If they are brittle, flaking or slipping in their own right, a patch simply moves the problem a metre along.
A section repair can start with the layer under the tiles. The damaged covering is lifted, the battens and underlay beneath it are looked over, anything rotten is cut out, and the covering is laid back. Skipping that check is how a repair fails within a season, because new tiles on a rotten batten have nothing to hold them.
The roof repairs page lists the faults that are repaired in this way.
The Planning Portal's test for partial work
Repairs raise the question of Building Regulations. In the Portal's re-roofing guide, no application is normally needed if "Less than 25 per cent of the total 'building envelope'" is affected and "Less than 50 per cent of the roof is affected". Both limits apply together, and the Portal's building envelope takes in the walls, the floor, the windows, the doors and any roof windows and roof-lights as well as the roof, so it is a wider measure than the roof alone.
The same guide warns that a new covering which increases the weight of the roof covering by "15 per cent or more" needs approval. A heavier covering is checked by a structural engineer or surveyor before work starts. Plan on the basis that any partial job which goes past either limit needs Building Regulations approval, and that the council's building control team or a registered building control approver deals with it.
Our guide on whether roof repairs need Building Regulations goes through the test in full. Where there is any doubt, we check the route with the council before work starts.
When patching stops making sense
Repair and replacement is a judgement about age, condition and cost. The points below suggest that a partial repair may be the wrong choice.
- Repairs are being made in several parts of the roof within a short period.
- The battens or rafters under the damage are soft, split or wet.
- The tiles crumble or flake when handled, so they cannot be lifted and re-laid.
- The underlay is torn or perished over a large area.
- The cost of repeated repairs is approaching the cost of a new covering.
- The roof is old enough that further faults are likely to appear beside the repair.
Matching is a practical question too. New tiles can look different from weathered ones in colour, and a patch can show as a lighter square for several years. Reclaimed tiles may blend better, and a roofer can say whether suitable ones can be found.
Our page on whether it is cheaper to repair or replace a roof compares the two. A survey gives one written total, so the repair can be set against the alternative before you decide. Keep in mind that a repair buys time and a replacement renews the covering, and the right choice depends on how much life the old covering has left.

