Call 01582 935272

Repairs and the rules

Do roof repairs need Building Regulations approval?

A repair and a re-roof are tested by the same rules, but not to the same result. This guide shows where a small repair stays inside the Planning Portal's limits and what turns it into work that needs approval.

9 minute read

Get a written quote

Call 01582 935272WhatsApp us

Cracked mortar bedding under the ridge of a concrete tile roof
PicturedCracked mortar bedding under the ridge of a concrete tile roof.
A roof drawing with its parts named: ridge tiles, tiles, battens, underlay, raftersRidge tilesTilesBattensUnderlayRafters

Repairs and the Planning Portal's test

Building Regulations are written around work to a building, and the Planning Portal's guide to re-roofing is the document most roof jobs are measured against. Its test is about how much of the building the work touches. A repair touches a little. A new covering touches nearly everything the roof is made of, from the tiles and battens to the underlay, so the same test gives a different answer.

The Portal's interactive guide sets two limits: "Less than 25 per cent of the total 'building envelope'" and "Less than 50 per cent of the roof is affected." Inside both, the Portal expects no application as a rule, and its own word for that is "normally". A handful of tiles, a length of ridge or a patch of lead sits well inside them, so a small repair stays clear of the question altogether. The roof repairs hub, roof repairs, lists the other repair jobs.

That word leaves room for exceptions, because the limits describe the starting position and not every job. A repair that adds weight, alters the structure or takes out part of a chimney does not stay inside the test just because the job is small, since each brings its own rule into play.

You might hear

A repair needs no approval because it is only a repair.

Plain as day

Approval turns on how much roof the work affects and what goes on it, not on the word repair.

Jobs that sit inside the limits

Everyday repairs measured against the Portal's limits
RepairShare of the roofPosition
Replacing a few slipped tilesA small patchInside both limits
Re-bedding a length of ridgeA line along the topInside both limits
Renewing a flashingA narrow stripInside both limits
Re-covering one slopeAbout halfAt the limit: ask first

The first three rows take in a small part of the roof, so the percentages are nowhere near the line. The last row is where the arithmetic matters. A slope can be half the roof, or less, or more, depending on the shape of the house, and the Portal's wording is "Less than 50 per cent". A job near that line is a question for the council's building control team.

Repair work can also turn out bigger than it looks from the ground. A failed underlay or rotten battens beneath a patch can turn a few tiles into a wider strip once the covering is lifted. In that case the area that counts is the area actually opened up, so the measure is taken on the roof and not from the first estimate.

Can you repair part of a roof looks at the practical side of mending one area and leaving the rest. The same limits apply to whichever area is chosen, so the choice of area can be checked against them before the work is booked.

When a repair adds weight

Area is only one test. The Planning Portal's re-roofing guide also asks for approval if a new covering material "increases the weight of the roof covering by 15 per cent or more." A repair that swaps a section of covering for a different, heavier product can meet that test however small the patch.

Approved Document A puts the idea in its own terms, as a roof load "increased by more than 15%". The two documents use slightly different words, so whichever figure a page quotes should be named with its source. Neither says which materials are heavier; the sums use the real weights of the old and new coverings from the makers' data sheets.

On a heavier covering, the Portal's page says "you are advised to check with a structural engineer or surveyor before commencing with works". The rafters and walls were built for the load of the original covering, and an increase is a structural question before it is a roofing one.

A second condition sits beside weight. Approval is also needed where "The performance of any new covering will be significantly different to that of the existing covering in the event of a fire". Matching the existing covering in kind, as well as in appearance, keeps a small patch clear of both triggers.

Structure, chimneys and what the Portal rules out

The Portal's list of reasons to seek approval goes beyond coverings. Structural alterations come under it, and so does any change that goes past the limits above. Strengthening a rafter, cutting a new opening or removing a timber that carries load is structural work, whatever the size of the repair around it.

Chimney work has its own rule. "Building regulations approval will always apply when removing chimney breasts", the Portal says, and when a party wall carries the breast a party wall notice is needed as well, served at least two months ahead for work to a party structure. The chimney guide, chimney breast removal regulations, covers the steps.

Mending the parts of a chimney that sit on the roof is a different job. A flashing, a pot or a stretch of pointing is a repair. On the planning side, Class C excludes "the installation, alteration or replacement of a chimney, flue or soil and vent pipe", and that sentence belongs to planning rather than to Building Regulations, so for roof-side detail go to planning permission for roof work.

  • a new covering that is 15 per cent or more heavier
  • a covering that behaves differently in a fire
  • structural alteration to rafters, purlins or walls
  • removing a chimney breast

Flat roof repairs and the waterproof membrane

Part L of the Building Regulations adds a second thread for flat roofs. Approved Document L lists what renovation includes, and one entry is "Replacing the waterproof membrane on a flat roof." A patch over a split or a blister is a repair, but a new membrane across the whole deck is renovation of the roof element.

Paragraph 11.3 sets the trigger as "More than 50% of the surface of the individual thermal element is renovated", and the upgrade follows where it is feasible. Table 4.3 pairs a 0.35 threshold with an improved 0.16, both in W/m²K, for a roof. Paragraph 4.13 adds a payback test: where the table figure fails it, the roof goes as far as it can within a "simple payback of 15 years or less".

The same paragraph reaches pitched roofs, which is why a whole-roof job is judged on insulation as well as on the Portal's test. Replacing a few tiles is nowhere near that line, and neither is a patch to a flat roof. The calculation is made on the surface of the whole element, and a small area against a large roof is a small share, so the same patch on a bigger roof counts for even less.

Flat roof building regulations covers the flat-roof detail in full, and the figures above are the ones the pitched-roof guides use too. Insulation figures matter most to anyone planning a new membrane, because that is the job that crosses the line, and the choice of membrane is made with them in view.

Emergency work and the paperwork afterwards

A leak, a slipped patch of tiles or a storm gap needs making safe before anything else. Tarpaulins, temporary fixings and a boarded opening keep the weather out while the permanent repair is planned, and that stage is temporary work rather than a lasting change to the roof. Emergency roof repairs: making a roof safe covers it.

The permanent repair then follows the tests above. If a storm caused the damage, take photos while it is untouched, because the Financial Ombudsman Service says it will "usually look at expert reports and photos", and tell the insurer soon after, so a clear set of pictures helps if a claim is later disputed. The building control question and the insurance question run side by side and do not depend on each other.

Where a repair does need an application, the council's building control team or a registered building control approver takes it. Certificates differ by route: a completion certificate from the council, a final certificate from a registered approver. Whichever arrives is worth filing with the property papers. Roof repairs in a conservation area or on a listed house raise planning questions as well, which are separate again, and that guide goes through them.

Who to ask, and what to keep

Building control is carried out by the council's building control team or by a registered building control approver. Central Bedfordshire Council, Luton Council, Bedford Borough Council, Milton Keynes City Council and Buckinghamshire Council each run their own service. For a house near a boundary, the council that matters is the one whose area the address falls in.

A fair question to put to anyone quoting for repair work is which of the triggers above could apply to the job in front of them: area, weight, structure, a chimney or a flat-roof membrane. A written quote that names the covering being fitted answers the weight question at once, while a vague one leaves that question hanging.

A dated photo set of the roof, taken both ahead of the work and once it ends, is worth keeping, along with the written quote, the maker's data sheet for any new covering and any certificate from building control. Together they answer later questions from a buyer, an insurer or a surveyor.

Our own part is short. A survey precedes the quote, and where an application is needed we check the route with the council's building control team before work starts. The written price is one total that follows the survey.

Roof repairs and approval: five questions

01Does replacing a few roof tiles need an application?

In the Planning Portal's test, an application is not normally required where the work affects less than 25 per cent of the building envelope and less than 50 per cent of the roof. A few replacement tiles are a small share of the roof, so they sit well inside both limits. The Portal's own word "normally" is why a job close to either limit is worth raising with building control.

02What makes a small repair need approval?

A new covering that is 15 per cent or more heavier needs approval however small the patch, and so does one that performs differently in a fire. Structural alterations and chimney breast removal also fall outside the limits. Size alone does not settle it, because weight, structure and fire performance are tested alongside area, and each is checked against its own source.

03Does patching a flat roof trigger the Part L figures?

A patch over a split or blister does not. Replacing the waterproof membrane across a flat roof is renovation, and where more than 50% of the roof surface is renovated, Approved Document L expects the roof to be upgraded where feasible. Table 4.3 pairs a threshold of 0.35 with an improved figure of 0.16, both in W/m²K, and building control applies them to the house.

04Is making a leaking roof safe covered by the Regulations?

Making a roof safe is temporary work to keep the weather out, and it sits apart from the permanent repair. The permanent repair is then judged on the tests in this guide. Photograph the damage while it is untouched, and tell your insurer: the Financial Ombudsman Service says it will usually look at expert reports and photos, so a clear set helps if a claim is disputed.

05Who gives approval for a roof repair that needs it?

The council's building control team or a registered building control approver. A council issues a completion certificate when work meets the Regulations, and a registered approver issues a final certificate. Ask the team for the council in whose area the house stands, and keep whichever certificate you receive with the papers for the property, alongside the written quote and the dated photographs from before and after the work.

Get a written price for your roof

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing

Tell us about your roof

Call WhatsApp Written quote