Call 01582 935272

Roof replacement

Choosing a covering for a new roof

Clay, concrete and slate each suit some roofs and rule out others. This guide compares the published lifespans, pitches and fixing rules for each, and shows which questions settle the choice before a quote is written.

9 minute read

Get a written quote

Call 01582 935272WhatsApp us

A loft room lit by two roof windows between the rafters
PicturedA loft room lit by two roof windows between the rafters.
A roof drawing with its parts named: ridge tiles, tiles, battens, underlay, raftersRidge tilesTilesBattensUnderlayRafters

Three families of covering

Published guides to new roofs keep returning to three families: clay tiles, concrete tiles and natural slate. Each comes in several profiles. A plain tile is a small flat tile laid in overlapping courses, a pantile has a curved profile and interlocks with its neighbours, and a slate is a thin sheet of natural stone fixed by nails or hooks.

The family is only the starting point. Within clay, one maker's range runs from a plain tile to a pantile, and each product has its own limits on pitch and fixing. Within slate, the origin of the stone sets the price and the lifespan, as the Welsh, Spanish and reclaimed Welsh figures further down show, and reclaimed slate carries a shorter published range than new Welsh slate.

A covering is also judged against the house. The pitch of the roof, the weight the rafters were built to carry, the look of the street and any listing or conservation area all feed into the choice, and the maker's data sheet for a product is read as carefully as the headline claim for its family.

Photographs of other roofs say little about what suits yours. The rules below apply wherever the house stands, and a survey establishes what is on your own roof today. They apply to every roof replacement, from a bungalow to a terrace.

Lifespans as published

Several sources give lifespans, and they use different words. HomeBuilding, on a page last updated on 30 September 2025, gives approximate figures. Marley, the tile maker, says "Typically, roof tiles are expected to last for around 60 years" and adds "This is not a guarantee or warranty of its longevity." The BRE determined a minimum life expectancy of 60 years for clay tiles, and for zinc VMZinc says a correctly designed and installed roof "can last in excess of 100 years".

Approximate lifespans, as published by HomeBuilding
CoveringLifespan (approx)
Welsh slate100+ years
Spanish natural slate75-100 years
Reclaimed Welsh slate50-80 years
Clay tiles60-80 years
Plain concrete tiles40-50 years

For concrete, Marley's "around 60 years" for roof tiles and HomeBuilding's 40-50 years differ, and neither figure is offered as a forecast for a particular house. A lifespan figure is an expectation taken from a published guide, so it informs a choice without deciding it. Care of the roof and the quality of the installation shape how long any covering lasts, and so does keeping gutters clear and replacing a cracked tile promptly.

Flashings run on their own clock. MyJobQuote says correctly installed lead flashing "can last for over 80 years", which is a statement about the lead and not about the tiles beside it. How long a new roof lasts takes the figures further.

Pitch decides what can go on

Each product carries its own minimum pitch, the lowest angle at which it sheds water as designed. Marley publishes the figure product by product. The names in the table are Marley's own product names, so Canterbury, Anglia and Ludlow are tiles and not places.

Minimum pitches for some Marley products
TileTypeMinimum pitch
CanterburyClay40°
AshdowneClay35°
Lincoln pantileClay15°
PlainConcrete35°
Double RomanConcrete22.5°
MendipConcrete15°

Natural slate is covered by a different source. Cupa reports that BS 5534 "also indicates that the minimum roof pitch for natural slate is 20 degrees in the case of a project situated in an area with moderate exposure and with a slate 500mm long and a 115mm overlap", and adds "hook fixings should not be used on any pitch below 25º".

A shallow roof narrows the choice, and switching family can mean a different pitch limit. The angle of the existing roof is therefore measured before a covering is chosen, since a product that looks right on a data sheet can be ruled out by a few degrees on the slope.

The same table also explains why a house cannot always take the covering a neighbour has. Two houses of similar age can have different pitches, and a roof that was extended or altered later can have more than one pitch on the same building, with a different limit on each part.

Fixing and ventilation behind the covering

BS 5534:2014+A2:2018 is the current British Standard for slating and tiling. Marley is plain that installing to it "isn't required by law", but the 2015 amendments made it clear that mortar "could no longer be relied upon as the only means of securing the roof covering". A new roof is therefore fixed with clips, nails or screws as well as any mortar bedding.

How a tile is fixed depends on where the roof stands. Marley says the BS 5534 minimums "will always be superseded by the generation of a Fixing Specification, which is site specific", so each roof's fixing pattern is worked out for how exposed that site is, and no single table settles it. For the ridge it says: "In all cases, ridge or hip tiles should be mechanically fixed to resist the calculated wind uplift force."

BS 8612:2018 is also current, and it is the standard to look for where the ridge, hips and verges are fixed dry instead of being bedded in mortar. How those edges are finished is one detail a quote should name.

Behind the covering sits the underlay. With a high-resistance underlay in a cold roof, Marley gives 25 mm of eaves ventilation at 15° or less and 10 mm above 15°, and its material does not pass water vapour. The covering and underlay are chosen as a pair, which is one more reason the pitch comes first, and the ventilation detail is written into the specification, not left to the day.

A heavier covering and the rafters

Load is the other thing a new covering changes. The Planning Portal sets its trigger in its own words: approval is needed where the new covering "increases the weight of the roof covering by 15 per cent or more". Approved Document A uses a different yardstick, a roof loading "increased by more than 15%", which it calls a significant change.

Neither source names one family of covering as the lighter or the heavier choice, so the sums are done for the product being considered, on the roof being covered, and not from a general belief. On re-roofing, the Portal's page says "you are advised to check with a structural engineer or surveyor before commencing with works".

A second trigger concerns fire. The Portal lists the case where "The performance of any new covering will be significantly different to that of the existing covering in the event of a fire" as one that needs approval.

Either way, a full re-roof is seen by the council's building control team or by a registered building control approver, and ahead of the start date we put the route to the council. A like-for-like tile is therefore not the only thing that keeps a job simple: the weight and fire performance of the new product, set against the old, are the figures that decide whether more is needed.

Heritage rules on the covering

A listed house brings the covering choice into the council's view, and a house in a conservation area raises the question of an Article 4 direction. Works that touch the building's character need listed building consent, and a different covering can do that. The detail is in replacing a roof on a listed building.

In a conservation area, Class C still lets a house be re-roofed as permitted development, and a dormer needs an application. An Article 4 direction, which each council lists for itself, can remove permitted development rights from a defined area, so the council's list is checked for the street.

No rule names the covering that a particular listed or conservation-area roof must use. The council decides that case by case, with the roof and the proposed material in front of it. A sample, a data sheet and a photo of a similar finished roof help that conversation.

  • the product name and maker
  • the minimum pitch it needs, against the roof's measured pitch
  • how it is fixed
  • its published lifespan, with the source named

Bringing those four items to the council at the start saves a second round of questions later, and it keeps the conversation about the roof in front of everyone, not a general idea of roofs.

Choosing between them, and the price

A sensible choice starts from the roof's pitch, its structure and the listing question, then moves to the lifespan wanted and the price. Before a survey the price can be read only from published guides. HomeBuilding's example is a three-bedroom semi, 65m² of roof, plain concrete tiles, which "may cost between £10,000 and £15,000", while Welsh slate for the same property "might reach £18,000".

MyJobQuote says "The average cost of fitting a slate roof is around £7,800." That figure and HomeBuilding's cannot be joined, because the pages describe different roofs. They agree on direction: natural slate costs more at the start than plain concrete tiles, and the lifespan figures run longer.

Questions that settle the covering
QuestionWhy it matters
What is the pitch?Sets the minimum pitch limit for each product
Is it listed or in a conservation area?Brings in the council's view
What do the rafters carry now?Weight changes need checking
How long will you stay?Sets the value of a longer lifespan

New roof costs and what sets the price sets out the wider figures. A written quote then gives one total price for the covering chosen and the roof surveyed, with the pitch, fixings and ridge details described in plain words so that the work can be checked against the product's data sheet.

Questions on roof coverings

01Is slate better than concrete tiles?

They are different products with different published figures. HomeBuilding gives Welsh slate 100+ years and plain concrete tiles 40-50 years, and it puts slate higher in price. Slate is not suited to every pitch, and its fixings change with the angle, so check the minimum pitch for the product and measure the roof before comparing the two on cost or on lifespan.

02What is the lowest pitch for roof tiles?

It depends on the product. Marley lists 15° for the Lincoln clay pantile and for the Mendip and Wessex concrete ranges, 35° for the Ashdowne clay tile and the Plain concrete tile, and 40° for the Canterbury clay tile. For natural slate, Cupa reports 20 degrees under BS 5534 at moderate exposure, and no hook fixings below 25º. Read the product's own data sheet for the exact figure.

03Does the covering need to be mortared on?

Mortar alone cannot be relied on. Marley says the 2015 amendments to BS 5534 mean mortar could no longer be relied upon as the only means of securing the roof covering; mechanical fixings are used. The fixing specification for the site sets the pattern, because exposure differs from one site to the next, and ridge and hip tiles get their own mechanical fixing.

04Will a new covering need Building Regulations approval?

A full re-roof does, under the Planning Portal's guide. A new covering that adds 15 per cent or more to the roof covering's weight brings approval into it too, and a structural engineer or surveyor should see the roof first. The council's building control team or a registered building control approver deals with the application, and a written quote is given once the roof has been seen.

05Can I change from one covering to another?

A roof can take a different covering when its pitch allows the product, the rafters carry the new weight and no listing or conservation rule says otherwise. Each of those is a rule or a council decision, so settle all three before an order is placed, and ask the council about any heritage question first, since a refusal after delivery is expensive for everyone.

Get a written price for your roof

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing

Tell us about your roof

Call WhatsApp Written quote