Three towns, three councils, one question
St Albans is in the St Albans City and District Council area. Hitchin is in North Herts Council's. Olney is in Milton Keynes City Council's. Each council keeps its own conservation area records and its own Article 4 list, and each states different things about them. A homeowner asking whether a roof window can go into a front slope is therefore asking three different bodies three different questions, and a rule found for one town cannot be carried to the next.
The national position is the starting point. Roof windows fall under Class C of the General Permitted Development Order, the class for "Any other alteration to the roof of a dwellinghouse". A conservation area, as such, does not take Class C away. What can take it away is an Article 4 direction, which the government describes as one that "enables the Secretary of State or the local planning authority to withdraw specified permitted development rights across a defined area".
What each council publishes about its directions goes only as far as the council's own text. Where the text names an area without listing what it covers, the table says to ask, and that is the advice in this post: ask the council before ordering anything.
| Place | Council | What its list says |
|---|---|---|
| Hitchin | North Herts Council | Covers alterations to a roof of a dwellinghouse, among other matters |
| Olney | Milton Keynes City Council | Reaches extensions, alterations, porches and painting of outside walls |
| St Albans | St Albans City and District Council | Names four main areas; ask the council what each removes |
What Class C and Class B each decide
Class C covers the other alterations to roofs, and the government's householder guidance puts it plainly: "Class C covers other alterations to roofs such as re-roofing or the installation of roof lights/windows." Its limits run from the original roof, a point the planning guide covers in full. For a roof window in a pitched slope, the limits keep the unit close to the slope and below the ridge.
Class B is a separate class, for roof enlargements such as dormers, and it does not apply on article 2(3) land, which includes conservation areas. That is why a dormer in a conservation area needs planning permission, while a roof window fitted flush to the slope is a different case. Moving from a roof window to a dormer moves the job from one class to the other, and from the ordinary route to a planning application.
One Class C condition catches side slopes. On such a slope the Order adds a requirement: the window has to be obscure-glazed, and non-opening unless the parts of the window which can be opened are more than 1.7 metres above the floor of the room in which the window is installed. The planning permission guide for roof windows goes through the tests, and a conservation area adds only the Article 4 question on top.
Hitchin: alterations to a roof are on the list
North Herts Council's page on conservation areas and Article 4 directions says that North Hertfordshire has 44 conservation areas. Hitchin and Stockens Green are each named, with an Article 4 direction attached to the conservation area. North Herts Council's own wording says the directions cover, among other matters, "alterations to a roof of dwellinghouse" and "installation, alteration or replacement of a chimney, flue or soil and vent pipe".
Because Class C is the class that covers roof lights and windows, a direction aimed at roof alterations is the one that bears on a roof window in a Hitchin house inside the area. The council's wording does not mention roof windows by name, so what a given window needs is for North Herts Council to confirm in writing. Do not read a missing word as permission, and do not read the direction's existence as a ban either. It means an application may be needed where one would not be elsewhere.
Building control is a separate matter, and in Hitchin it is supplied by Hertfordshire Building Control Ltd (01438 879990), a company with North Herts Council among its local-authority owners. The two bodies answer different questions: the council's planners on planning permission and the Article 4 direction, and building control on the window's energy figures and any structural change to the rafters.
Olney: matching materials in a direction's own words
Milton Keynes City Council lists a conservation-area Article 4 direction for Olney. Its text says that every dwellinghouse in the area is affected, but only for extensions and alterations, for porches, and for painting the outside walls. The council states that Milton Keynes has 27 conservation areas, and Wolverton has a direction of its own.
"Exterior brick, slate and stonework" appears in the council's own questions, which ask if it is "maintained as existing and matched where replacement is required". The pages also note that repairs which do not "materially affect the external appearance" are not development. That wording concerns repairs. A new opening cut into the slope is a change, not a like-for-like repair, so it is for the council to say if it falls inside the direction.
A word on tiles and slates, because the council's text names slate. In Olney, matching what is there is the test the council's Article 4 pages set out for exterior slate. If the slope you want to cut into has slates, ask the council what it expects the new surround and flashings to look like, and photograph the front elevation to send with the question. For Olney addresses, Milton Keynes City Council's building control team is on 01908 252721 in office hours.
St Albans: four named areas, then ask
St Albans City and District Council's page on Article 4 direction areas says there are four main areas covered by Article 4 Directions. In the council's own naming they are Cunningham Avenue, Childwickbury, Sopwell Lane with Albert Street, and Verulam with Fishpool Street. The council links to separate pages showing what each one removes, and these differ by area, so none of the four can be assumed to treat a roof window one way or the other.
If a house is in one of those areas, or near enough that the boundary is in doubt, the council's planning team can confirm which direction, if any, applies to the address and what it covers. Ask for the answer in writing and say what you want to fit: the number of windows, which slope, and the make, size and glazing. A precise question gets a precise reply, and a written one can be handed to the next owner along with the deeds.
St Albans and Watford councils run a shared building control service, and that is where building control for St Albans addresses sits. A registered building control approver is the other route. Neither gives a view on planning permission, so planning and building control are two enquiries, made to two different teams.
You might hear
Being in a conservation area means a roof window is banned.
Plain as day
A conservation area does not remove Class C. An Article 4 direction might, so ask the council.
Listed homes and flats are different cases
Listing is a separate layer. A listed house keeps its permitted development rights for roof work under Classes B and C, although the Act requires listed building consent for work carried out "in any manner which would affect its character as a building of special architectural or historic interest". Putting a window into a historic roof slope can plainly affect character, so the consent question comes before any planning one.
Flats are another exception. Under the Order, a building divided into flats is not a dwellinghouse, so flats have no householder permitted development rights, and a roof window to a flat goes to the council whatever the conservation area position. The same applies to the other side of a conversion: a house that has been divided into flats has lost the householder rights that applied before the division. Ask the council about the building's status as it stands today, and do not rely on a lease or an estate agent's description to settle it.
In both cases the order of questions is the same. Find out whether the building is listed, whether it is a house or flats, whether it is in a conservation area, and whether a direction applies. The answers come from the council, and the guide to roof windows in conservation areas gives the general version of the same checklist for any council.
The window itself, the scaffold and the price
Where planning allows a roof window, the unit still has to meet Part L. For a roof window the figure is 1.4 W/m²K or Window Energy Rating Band B minimum. Approved Document L classes a flush conservation rooflight with roof windows, so the same figure applies to it. A conservation-style unit is a choice about appearance, not a way round the energy requirement, and the data sheet shows which figure a product meets. Ask for that sheet before ordering, and keep it with the other papers for the job.
A roof window is fitted from the outside, and any scaffold reaching across the public highway comes under section 169 of the Highways Act 1980. The licence is one we arrange with our scaffolder. Hertfordshire County Council charges £134 for a 14-day scaffold licence and £59 for every week after, and for Hertfordshire addresses "It usually takes 3 weeks to process an application." Milton Keynes City Council lists a standard scaffolding licence of up to one month at £189 excluding VAT, which is the figure for Olney addresses.
Our survey comes before the quote, and what we quote is one total, in writing. We look at the slope, tell you plainly about anything else that shows on the roof, and put the whole job into a single figure. A photo of the front elevation can go to WhatsApp, 07880 284133, and we look at it, which helps before any council question is drafted. The skylights and roof windows hub covers fitting and replacement.
One written total
What sets the figure
The unit chosen, the covering it is cut into, the pitch, the access to the slope and any matching the council asks for around the opening all decide it. One written total follows the survey.

