Water spilling over the edge
The plainest sign is water coming over the front of the gutter during rain. In a downpour a little spray is not alarming, but a continuous curtain falling from the edge is. The water that should be running along the channel to the outlet is leaving by the lowest route instead.
A blocked outlet is the first thing to rule out. Leaves, silt and moss collect over the opening, and the channel fills behind them. If the spill is at one spot, the blockage can sit just there. If the gutter spills along most of its length, the channel may be full or the downpipe may be failing to clear.
A gutter that spills while clear is a different case. It can mean the fall has been lost, the channel has sagged, or the run is handling more roof than it was set up for, such as after an extension was added. That is a fault in the gutter, and clearing it will not cure it.
| Look for | Points to | Next step |
|---|---|---|
| Spill at one spot | Blocked outlet | Look from the ground after rain |
| Spill along the run | Full channel or blocked downpipe | Hose test the downpipe |
| Spill with a clear channel | Lost fall or sag | Photograph it in rain |
Drips at joints and corners
A steady drip from a joint between two lengths of gutter, or from a corner, shows that the seal has failed. You will see it as a bead of water forming on the underside of the joint, a damp mark on the brickwork beneath it or a dark trail down the render.
Joints are where a gutter can leak because they are where separate parts meet. Rubber seals harden with age, brackets can pull a joint slightly apart and a run that has moved under the weight of leaves or ice can open a gap that was sealed once. A drip that only happens in heavy rain suggests a small gap, while one that runs in light rain suggests a larger one.
- a bead of water on the underside of a union
- a dark vertical streak on the wall below a joint
- green growth under one corner
- a puddle in the same place on the path after rain
The same spot, wet again and again, is more telling than a single drip. Where the joint has been resealed before, a new drip suggests the run is moving at that point. Watching the joint during rain, and noting whether the leak comes from the seal itself or from the stretch just above it, gives a clearer picture than a glance on a dry day.
The repair or replace guide covers when a reseal is enough and when the run has had its day.
Stains and damp on the wall
Marks on the wall below the gutter are the evidence that the gutter has been leaking for some time. A vertical green or black streak that starts at a joint or an outlet and runs down the brick or render is a track left by water that has run the same way again and again.
Inside the house, damp can show itself too. A brown stain on a ceiling beside an external wall, a patch of peeling paint near the top of a wall or a musty smell in an upstairs corner can be a sign that water has been getting into the wall. A gutter is only one possible cause. A damaged roof covering or a leak elsewhere can produce similar marks, so it is worth looking at the whole roofline and not assuming.
A look in the loft after rain, where there is safe access, can show whether water is coming in at the eaves. Photograph any stain alongside a ruler for scale, and jot down the day it appeared.
A wall that stays damp can also let in cold. If the plaster inside is cold to the touch and marked, the cause is worth tracking down, and the gutter is a good first place to look because it is the part of the roof that puts water against the wall.
A gutter that sags or leans
A run that droops between brackets, tilts away from the wall or has a visible belly in the middle is no longer holding its line. You can see it by standing back and looking along the roof edge: the gutter should run straight and slightly downhill towards the outlet, and any wave or dip stands out.
Sagging has several causes. A bracket can work loose, the fascia behind it can go soft, the weight of leaves and standing water can pull the channel down or ice can bend it. A dip of a few millimetres is enough to hold a pool, because the proper fall is gentle: Brett Martin gives 1 mm for every 600 mm.
Standing water in a sagging section makes the problem grow. The pool adds weight, the weight bends the channel further and the water that remains breeds moss and silt. A sag that is new and small is easier to put right than a long-standing one.
| Look for | Points to | Next step |
|---|---|---|
| Belly between brackets | Loose or missing bracket | Note where the dip is |
| Gutter pulling from wall | Soft fascia or failed screws | Press the board with a thumb |
| Pool that stays after rain | Lost fall | Photograph it the next day |
You might hear
A slightly drooping gutter is only untidy.
Plain as day
A small sag can hold a pool, and the pool adds weight to the dip.
Fascia boards that are soft or flaking
The fascia behind the gutter shows its own signs. Paint that has cracked, bubbled or peeled leaves bare timber open to water. A dark patch that stays damp, a board that has split along the grain or one that has dropped away from the soffit at a corner are all worth noting.
The thumb test is simple. Press the underside of the board and the cut ends. Wood that gives, feels spongy or crumbles is rotten, and it will not hold a bracket. A gutter fixed to rotten timber sags again, so the board has to be sorted out ahead of refitting the gutter.
On uPVC, the signs look different. A board that has bowed, cracked near its ends or opened at a joint is losing its shape, and a board that has turned from white to a yellow or chalky shade has had long exposure to the weather. One retailer's line puts correctly installed uPVC fascia boards at between 20 and 40 years, and our guide to how long fascias and soffits last covers it.
- paint peeling in sheets or bubbling
- timber that gives under a thumb
- a board that has split along the grain
- a uPVC board that has bowed or opened at a joint
- gaps between the fascia and soffit
Rust, cracks and gaps
The gutter itself can show its age. Cast iron or steel that has gone rusty, with flaking paint or brown stains, is thinning, and a hole can follow. Plastic that has turned chalky or has hairline cracks is brittle, and it can break when touched.
Gaps matter too. A gap between the end of a gutter and the stop end, between a gutter and its downpipe or where the gutter meets the wall of a neighbouring house lets water escape. Plants growing out of the channel or the joints are a sign that silt has built up and held water for long enough for seeds to root.
A downpipe that is standing off its bracket, one with a crack or a bulge, or one that discharges water onto the wall instead of down a drain, is also worth noting. A downpipe is part of the same system, and a fault there sends water to the wrong place even when the gutter above is perfect.
Older houses need extra care. HSE advises treating any property built or refurbished before 2000 as if it holds asbestos. Where a gutter, downpipe or soffit is old and cracked, do not scrub, drill or break it, and see the asbestos soffits guide first.
What to do next
Write down what you see before you do anything else. Note where each sign is, what the weather was and whether it has changed over a few weeks. A few photographs of the worst spots and one of the whole run give the clearest record, and they can go straight to 07880 284133 on WhatsApp. Work from the least intrusive step to the most, and keep each record dated so that a pattern shows up over several wet spells.
Do not climb onto the roof or lean a ladder on the gutter to look closer. Binoculars, a window or a walk round the garden show most of what matters. Leave anything at height to someone equipped for it. A written list helps when you speak to anyone about the work. Put the signs in the order you noticed them, with the place on the house and whether the water comes with light or heavy rain. A clear account of that kind makes a survey quicker to plan and makes it easier to compare what different firms say about the same roofline.
One sign on its own can be a small repair, while three or four together can show that the whole run is tired. We survey the roof before quoting. Afterwards you get an account of what was found, plus one written total for whatever the roofline needs.
The guttering, fascia and soffit costs guide gives dated third-party figures for scale. Prefer to talk? Call 01582 935272.

