The short answer
A structural engineer is not needed for every new roof. If the Planning Portal's 15 per cent or more test is met, with a new covering heavier than the one it replaces, you are told to check with a structural engineer or surveyor before work starts, and Approved Document A treats a roof load increased by more than 15% as a significant change.
When a new covering is heavier
The Planning Portal gives the test in two parts. Building Regulations approval is needed if "You use a new covering material which increases the weight of the roof covering by 15 per cent or more." Its re-roofing page then tells you to check with a structural engineer or surveyor before commencing with works. Approved Document A, the part dealing with structure, words the line a little differently: "A significant change in roof loading is when the loading upon the roof is increased by more than 15%."
The figure that matters is the weight of the covering as a whole: tiles or slates, their fixings and the battens that carry them. The comparison uses the makers' own numbers for the old product and the new one. No rule names one material as heavier than another, so your answer comes from laying two real data sheets side by side, not from a belief about what tiles or slate weigh.
If the sums land on or over the line, the check comes before the tiles are ordered, because the result may change the covering you choose. The roof covering options page sets out the alternatives, and the wider rules are in the guide to new roof Building Regulations and Part L.
Other jobs that can bring one in
Weight is the headline trigger for a plain re-roof, and a few other jobs can raise the same question. None of them is a rule that every roof must follow, and each is decided by the roof in front of you.
- Taking out a chimney breast. The Planning Portal says Building regulations approval will always apply when removing chimney breasts, which it treats as a structural matter.
- Cutting into rafters for a roof window, a dormer or a new opening, since the timbers carry the load.
- Rot, sagging or movement found once the old covering is lifted and the timbers lie open.
- Structural alterations of any kind, which the Planning Portal lists among the reasons approval is needed.
A roofer's survey covers the tiles, the lead and any rafters in view, so that a written price can be given. It is not a structural engineer's report and does not stand in for one. If the survey leaves a doubt about the frame, get an engineer's view before the covering goes on, so a new roof is not laid on a structure that needs work.
How the check fits the approval
Building control is carried out by the council's building control team or by a registered building control approver. Council building control issues a completion certificate; a registered building control approver issues a final certificate. Either body can say what it wants to see for a heavier covering, which may include the engineer's findings, and asking early avoids a surprise once the work is under way.
The engineer works for you, or for the contractor, and sets their own fee, so ask for it before you book. Their findings can shape what is built. The price in writing for the roof is a single total, given once the survey is complete. We put the planning and building-control questions to the council ahead of any start, and the roof replacement page describes the whole job from survey to finish. Scaffolding on the pavement or road needs a scaffold licence from the highway authority; we arrange the licence with our scaffolder.
A full re-roof exceeds the Planning Portal's 50 per cent roof test, so it needs approval, heavier or not. The engineer question is separate: weight, a chimney breast or what the timbers show is what raises it.

