The short answer
A new roof can need new insulation. If more than half of a roof is renovated, AD L expects the whole roof to be brought up to the Table 4.3 standard where that is feasible: an improved U-value of 0.16, with 0.35 as the threshold. Where it is not, the upgrade is cut back to what can be done.
What Part L asks of a re-roof
Approved Document L is the part of the Building Regulations on saving fuel and power, and it treats roof work as renovation once enough of the roof is involved. Paragraph 11.3 gives the trigger: "More than 50% of the surface of the individual thermal element is renovated". A roof is one such element, and the document lists "Replacing the waterproof membrane on a flat roof." among the works that count. A full re-covering of a pitched roof is past half in the same way.
The consequence is stated in the document's Table 4.3, which gives a roof two numbers, a threshold of 0.35 and an improved figure of 0.16, both in watts per square metre per degree. In the document's wording, a renovated roof, or a retained roof above the 0.35 threshold in a loft conversion, is upgraded to Table 4.3's improved 0.16 where feasible. The lower a U-value, the less heat the element lets through.
A roof already better than the threshold is not caught by this rule. Because the insulation lies out of sight under the covering and above the ceiling, the build-up is confirmed as the work proceeds, and building control is the body that judges compliance. The 2021 edition of the document applies today, and AD L 2026 applies from 24 March 2027, with its tables renumbered.
When the upgrade is not feasible
Part L does not demand the impossible. Paragraph 4.13 deals with a roof where the improved figure "is not technically or functionally feasible" or "would not achieve a simple payback of 15 years or less". Where the full upgrade is not feasible or would not pay back within 15 years, the roof is upgraded as far as is feasible within that payback, and no further. The tests are applied to the roof in front of the designer, not to roofs in general.
- Technical or functional feasibility: whether the construction allows more insulation to be fitted without creating other faults, such as lost headroom or blocked airflow.
- Payback: whether the energy saved would repay the cost within 15 years.
- The fallback: whichever U-value is the lowest that pays back in time.
Airflow can be what limits an upgrade. With a high-resistance underlay in a cold roof, Marley gives 25 mm of eaves ventilation at 15° or less and 10 mm above 15°. Air permeability in that set-up belongs to the covering, and the underlay itself is not vapour-permeable. Pushing extra insulation into the eaves can choke the gap left for that air, so thickness and ventilation are settled together.
VAT, schemes and the written price
Insulating a roof or loft in a home is zero-rated for VAT until 31 March 2027, under HMRC's Notice 708/6, after which the reduced rate of 5% applies. That covers the insulation work. The notice sets no rate for the covering, and our written quote is one total price after the survey, so ask for it before you compare options.
The government schemes open in England list insulation, such as loft insulation, and heating upgrades rather than roof replacement; check GOV.UK for what you can get. Timing matters for one of them. The Energy Company Obligation is closing on 31 December 2026, so check GOV.UK or your council soon if you think you qualify. Another scheme has an income test: if your household income is usually £36,000 a year or less and your home is privately owned with an EPC of D to G, you may be eligible for the Warm Homes: Local Grant; check your eligibility on GOV.UK.
The guide to new roof Building Regulations and Part L goes through the energy rules at greater length, and the roof replacement page sets out the service. Insulation questions on a full re-roof are settled with building control, and we check the planning or building-control route with the council before work starts.

