Call 01582 935272

Roof claims

Commercial roof damage and insurance

A damaged commercial roof raises two questions at once: how to keep water out, and what the policy covers. Both are answered in order below, with the Financial Ombudsman Service's wording on storms and photographs.

9 minute read

Get a written quote

Call 01582 935272WhatsApp us

Rear flat roofs of a brick shop parade with flats above
PicturedRear flat roofs of a brick shop parade with flats above.
A roof drawing with its parts named: rooflights, roller shutter, gutterRooflightsRoller shutterGutter

A claim rests on the policy, not on the roof

Whether a damaged roof is paid for is decided by the insurance policy and its schedule, not by how bad the roof looks. A commercial policy names what is covered, what is excluded and what the policyholder has to do, and those terms differ from one policy to the next. The first job is to find the documents and read the sections on storm, water damage, wear and tear and the policyholder's duties, before anything on the roof is touched.

It also matters who holds the policy. A building can be owned by one business, let to another and managed by a third, and the roof may fall under the owner's policy, the tenant's, or a service charge arrangement. That is a question for the lease and the insurer. The insurer decides the claim, on the policy and the evidence.

  • The policy schedule and the full policy wording
  • When the damage came to light, and what the weather was doing
  • Who owns, rents and manages the building
  • Any earlier repairs to the same roof

Gather those four items before phoning the insurer for the first time. They are the questions a claims handler is likely to ask, and having them to hand keeps the conversation short.

When an insurer treats damage as storm damage

The Financial Ombudsman Service publishes guidance on storm damage to homes, and that guidance carries its storm wording. It says "a storm usually involves violent winds, usually with rain, hail or snow". It also says "Rain, hail or snowfall by itself can constitute a storm". The Ombudsman adds that the Beaufort Scale is one of the things it weighs. Those are the Ombudsman's words for deciding complaints about home insurance. A business policy can define a storm in its own terms, so the policy wording comes first.

A roof that leaks in a rain shower and a roof that has lost sheets in a gale are two different events, and an insurer may treat them differently. What caused the damage and how the policy defines it decide which category a loss falls into. Note the date of the damage, because the weather on that day can then be checked against the claim.

Water that appears after rain is not always a storm loss either. A blocked outlet, a failed lap or a worn flashing can let water in during an ordinary shower, and the insurer will want to know which it was. The reader's task is to record what happened and when, not to decide the category. If the weather report for that day is easy to find, save a copy of it with the photographs.

You might hear

A storm has to mean a gale.

Plain as day

The Ombudsman says rain, hail or snowfall by itself can constitute a storm. A policy may define the word differently.

Before anything is moved: photographs first

The Ombudsman says it will "usually look at expert reports and photos", so pictures of the damage as it stands, taken before any sheet or fragment is shifted, make the clearest record of the roof's condition. Take them from the ground and from inside the building, wide shots first and close shots second, and let the camera date-stamp each one.

  • The whole roof or elevation, so the damage can be placed on the building
  • Each damaged area close up, with a tape or a coin for scale
  • Displaced sheets, ridge parts or debris, where they landed
  • Stains, drips, wet ceiling tiles and wet insulation inside
  • Anything the damage has reached: stock, equipment, ceilings

If wind has carried a sheet or a fitting off the roof, note where it came to rest and leave it there until it has been photographed. Stay off the roof while taking the pictures. HSE's guidance says "AC roofs are always fragile", and a roof of unknown type should be treated as fragile until someone has established what it is. A fall is a worse outcome than a missing photograph, and a phone zoom from the ground or from an upper window gives a close enough view.

Tell the insurer before anything is moved or repaired, and follow the conditions in the policy. Keeping water out in the meantime is a separate question, and the policy conditions and the insurer can say what is expected.

Wear, maintenance and exclusions

A policy may exclude damage that has built up over time, and it may attach conditions about maintenance. The schedule says which applies to your cover. If an insurer points to an exclusion, the Ombudsman's stated position is that the burden of proof sits with the insurer, which can show it with an inspection report, for example. A refusal on that ground is a statement that can be tested, not a final word.

On who writes that report, the Ombudsman says "Your insurer will normally ask a surveyor to write a report." The insurer's surveyor works for the insurer. A roofer's survey is a separate matter: it looks at the covering, the fixings, the laps and flashings, and the state of the sheets or membrane, so that a repair or replacement can be priced.

  • Was the damage sudden, or had it been building up?
  • What was the weather on the date it was noticed?
  • What was the roof's condition before, and what had been done to it?
  • Does the policy attach conditions about upkeep?
  • Which exclusion, if any, is the insurer relying on?

Those are the questions an assessment turns on, and the answers sit in the policy and in the roof itself.

Asbestos, fragile sheets and the repair route

Damage can change what repair is possible. HSE's rule is "If the building was built or refurbished before 2000, assume that there is asbestos in it." On an older industrial or farm building the sheets may be asbestos cement, and HSE puts asbestos cement products in its non-licensed group where the material is "carefully handled/removed without breaking up", roof sheeting being one of its examples. HSE's notifiable non-licensed group covers asbestos cement "where the material has been substantially damaged or broken up (eg as a result of fire or flood damage)", which carries stricter requirements.

A storm that cracks or breaks cement sheets therefore does more than create a hole. It can move the job from careful removal to the category HSE treats as notifiable, and it changes who should go near the roof. Assess the material before anyone cuts, drills or lifts a sheet, and tell the insurer what was found. The page on fragile roofs and asbestos cement sheets sets out the HSE categories.

The repair is also construction work. CDM 2015 requires a construction phase plan for every project, and a principal contractor once more than one contractor is involved. A claim that pays for a roof repair does not remove those duties. The page on commercial roofing regulations covers them.

When the insurer says no: the complaint route

The Ombudsman's published steps are written for consumers. Before relying on them, ask the Financial Ombudsman Service itself, on 0800 023 4567, whether it can look at a complaint from your business. The order of the steps is the insurer first and the Ombudsman second. A short dated chronology helps at every stage: when the damage was found, when the insurer was told, what it replied and when.

Complaint steps as the Financial Ombudsman Service publishes them
StepWhat the Ombudsman says
First stageFor most complaints, a business has up to 8 weeks to consider a complaint
Second stageThe insurer sends its final response
Third stageYou have 6 months from the date on the final response

Six months is counted from the date on the face of the final response, so keep that letter. Keep every photograph, the policy schedule and all the correspondence together in one folder as well, because a complaint is weighed on the paperwork behind it. Dated pictures, an inspection report if the insurer produced one, and a note of each phone call all belong in that folder. If the roof has since been repaired, keep the invoice for the work too, since it shows what was found when the covering came off.

The written price for the repair

A roofer's quote and an insurance claim are two different documents. The insurer settles what it will pay, and the roofer prices the work. A commercial roof has its price set once the survey is done, since area, height, access, covering and fixings cannot be read from a photograph. The figure you are given is one written total price, and it follows the survey.

A photograph sent on WhatsApp (07880 284133) is a way to start, and we will look at it. When the survey is finished you hear plainly what the survey found, any further roof faults included. If the insurer wants to see a quote before it agrees a figure, ask it what it needs, and say whether the roof carries any scaffold on a pavement or road, because a Highways Act 1980 licence from the highway authority is then needed and we arrange the licence with our scaffolder.

Owners, tenants and managing agents each have an interest in the repair, so agree in writing who instructs the work and who receives the invoice before a roofer is asked to start. The commercial roofing hub describes the work taken on. The page on commercial roofing costs explains what moves a price, and none of it depends on whether an insurer is paying.

Questions about roof claims

01Does a commercial roof policy cover storm damage?

That depends on the policy. Read the schedule and the sections on storm, water damage and wear and tear, and ask the insurer if a clause is unclear. Never assume a loss is covered or excluded from the headline alone. The Financial Ombudsman Service describes a storm as something that usually involves violent winds, usually with rain, hail or snow, but a business policy can define the word its own way.

02Which photographs help with a roof damage claim?

Wide shots that place the damage on the building, close shots of each damaged area with a tape or coin for scale, displaced sheets where they landed, and the stains and drips inside. Take them first, from ground level or an upper window, and never from the roof itself. The Ombudsman says it will usually look at expert reports and photos.

03Should the roof be repaired before the insurer has seen it?

Tell the insurer first and follow the conditions in the policy, because the wording says what is expected before repairs begin. Photograph the damage first, ahead of any clearing, and keep any damaged material the insurer may want to see. How to keep water out until then is for the insurer to answer. A roofer's survey can run alongside the claim and does not replace the insurer's own assessment.

04What are the time limits for complaining about a refused roof claim?

The Financial Ombudsman Service says: "For most complaints, a business has up to 8 weeks to consider a complaint." Once a final response arrives, you have 6 months from its date to go to the Ombudsman. Those pages are written for consumers, so ask the Financial Ombudsman Service on 0800 023 4567 whether it can take a complaint from your business. Keep the policy, the photographs and the final response letter together.

05Does asbestos cement sheeting change a commercial roof claim?

It can change the repair. HSE's advice is "If the building was built or refurbished before 2000, assume that there is asbestos in it." Cement sheets that have broken up fall into a stricter group of work. Have the material assessed before anything is cut or lifted, and tell the insurer what is found. A roofer then prices the repair once the roof has been surveyed.

Get a written price for your roof

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing

Tell us about your roof

Call WhatsApp Written quote