Call 01582 935272

Roof safety

Fragile roofs and asbestos cement sheets

Two hazards can share an older commercial roof: a surface that cannot carry a person, and a material that may contain asbestos. What HSE says about each hazard comes first, then what has to happen before such a roof can be priced at all.

9 minute read

Get a written quote

Call 01582 935272WhatsApp us

Wind-torn membrane peeled back from a wet flat garage roof
PicturedWind-torn membrane peeled back from a wet flat garage roof.
A roof drawing with its parts named: rooflights, roller shutter, gutterRooflightsRoller shutterGutter

What fragile means on a roof

A fragile roof is one that cannot be relied on to carry a person's weight. The surface may look solid, with sheets bolted down in neat lines, and still give way underfoot, so the danger is invisible until someone steps on it. Going through a roof means a fall from height onto whatever is beneath, which is why fragility is treated as a hazard in its own right and not as a detail of the covering.

HSE's position on one commercial roofing material is unqualified. Its guidance says "AC roofs are always fragile". Asbestos cement sheets are the material in question, and the sentence leaves no case in which one of them can be treated as a safe walking surface.

For a roof of unknown type, the safe starting point follows from that. Until the covering has been identified and the way it is fixed is known, nobody walks on it, and nobody sends a member of staff up a ladder to clear a gutter or look at a leak. Access is arranged so that nobody has to stand on the sheets at all.

  • Do not walk on sheeting whose material is unknown
  • Do not rest a ladder on sheet edges or step off onto them
  • Do not drill, cut or lift sheets to see what lies under them
  • Photograph from the ground, a window or a neighbouring roof

What asbestos cement is, and where it was used

Asbestos cement is a mixture of cement and asbestos fibres, pressed into sheets. Profiled sheets of it were used to cover factories, warehouses, farm buildings, garages and industrial units, and corrugated sheeting for roofs and rainwater goods fall into HSE's description of asbestos cement products. Gutters and downpipes can be made of it as well, so a roof that was recovered long ago may still carry the old material at its eaves. That is why a survey of an older unit looks at the eaves, the gutters and the soffits as well as the main slopes.

The fibres are the hazard, and they are released when the material is broken, cut, drilled or abraded. Sheets in sound condition and left alone present a different situation from sheets that have cracked or been walked on. That difference is why HSE's groups, set out below, turn on how the material is handled and what condition it is in.

The material cannot be identified reliably by sight alone. Profiled sheeting made of other materials can look the same from the ground, and testing a sample is the way to settle it. The page on whether an asbestos cement roof is dangerous deals with the health question.

Built or refurbished before 2000

HSE gives a plain rule for deciding when to suspect asbestos: "If the building was built or refurbished before 2000, assume that there is asbestos in it." It is a rule about the building, and it is the right default for any unit, shed or workshop of that age until a survey or sampling shows otherwise.

The words "or refurbished" matter. A building put up in the 1960s and given a new cladding in the 1990s is inside the rule, and so is one that was extended or altered in that period. Nothing in the rule lets a customer assume that a newer-looking roof is clear, since the roof is just one element of the building that the rule describes. A customer can help by gathering a short list of facts: the year the unit was built, any refurbishment or re-cladding since, and any earlier asbestos survey that exists. An earlier survey, if there is one, is worth sending with the first photograph.

Assuming is not the same as knowing. The assumption keeps people safe while the facts are collected, and the facts then settle which of HSE's groups the work belongs to. A roof assessed and found to be free of asbestos changes the job, and a roof confirmed to be asbestos cement changes it in a different direction. In both cases the price is set after the answer is known.

Until then, the instruction to everyone with access to the roof is the same: leave the sheets alone.

HSE's three groups of work

HSE separates asbestos work into non-licensed, notifiable non-licensed and licensed. Which group a roof job falls into is decided by the material and its condition, and each group carries its own requirements. The table sets out the examples HSE gives for sheeting and for insulating board.

HSE's examples for asbestos cement and insulating board
GroupHSE's description
Non-licensedAsbestos cement roof sheeting "provided the material is carefully handled/removed without breaking up"
Notifiable non-licensedRoof sheeting "substantially damaged or broken up (eg as a result of fire or flood damage)"
LicensedWork "on AIB, where the risk assessment indicates that it will not be of short duration"

AIB is asbestos insulating board, and HSE lists "AIB white soffit panels to underside of roof eaves" among its locations, so a fascia and soffit job on an older building can meet it, and a damaged panel is on HSE's list as well. Licensed work is done only by contractors who are licensed for it, so a customer should ask any firm quoting for insulating board work what its licence covers.

These are HSE's groups and examples, in HSE's words. They are not a reason to attempt the work without understanding which group applies.

Why weathered sheets are not automatically a worse case

One worry is that an old, weathered sheet must belong in a stricter group simply because of its age. HSE's wording is more specific. Its non-licensed group says that it "includes work with asbestos cement which is weathered but not otherwise substantially damaged". Weathering on its own does not move a job into the notifiable group.

What moves it is damage: sheeting that has been broken up, as in a fire or a flood. A storm that cracks sheets, a fall of branches onto a roof or an attempt to lift a brittle sheet can all produce that condition, and once material is broken it is no longer the case that it is being removed whole.

That is the reason breakage matters more than age. A weathered sheet that is lifted whole and handled with care is one thing, and a sheet that snaps as it is lifted is another. It also explains why a roof survey looks at how the sheets are fixed, whether they are cracked and whether any have already broken.

None of this makes it safe to try a lift to see what happens. The assessment comes first, and the method of removal is chosen from what it shows. Cracked sheets are therefore a reason to stop and assess, and not a reason to hurry a patch onto the roof.

Waste: the lockable skip and the paperwork

Sheets that come off a roof become waste with its own rules. HSE's guidance is "Use a lockable skip for asbestos", and it adds that it is not good enough to throw sheeting over a standard skip. The point of the rule is containment: the material has to be enclosed while it waits to leave the site.

The paperwork has a trap as well. The household exemption from the hazardous waste consignment note covers domestic waste "(other than asbestos waste)", which leaves asbestos waste outside the exemption, and the paperwork for it has to be agreed with the carrier, not assumed. Hazardous waste carriers sit on a register with two levels, upper and lower, and the carrier is worth asking about before the job starts.

  • Is the skip lockable, and is it delivered before the sheets come down?
  • Who is the registered waste carrier for the asbestos, and which tier is it on?
  • Are the consignment note arrangements for this job agreed?
  • Where will the skip stand, and does that need a highway licence?

A skip standing on a road or pavement may need a licence of its own. Scaffolding on the highway needs a Highways Act 1980 scaffold licence from the highway authority. We arrange the licence with our scaffolder.

From survey to written price

The order of events on a fragile or suspect roof is fixed by what has to be known before anything else can be decided. The survey of the roof, from safe positions, comes first. Then comes the identification of the material. Then the route follows from the group, and the construction phase plan covers access, edge protection and waste. Only when those are known can a price be written.

Every figure waits for the survey. Afterwards the findings are set out in plain words, including other faults noticed on the roof, followed by one written total price. A photo sent to WhatsApp (07880 284133) is a good first step. The survey also looks at how the sheets are fixed, whether any are cracked, and where the rooflights, valleys and gutters sit. Say how old the building is, whether it has been refurbished, and whether the sheets are cement or metal.

Related questions are covered on the commercial roofing regulations page, and on the page about commercial roofing costs. The commercial roofing hub describes the work taken on.

Whatever the roof turns out to be, the first rule stands: nobody walks on it until the material is known, and that applies to owners, tenants and staff as much as to contractors.

Questions about fragile roofs

01Is it safe to walk on an asbestos cement roof?

No. HSE's guidance says "AC roofs are always fragile", which leaves no case in which the sheets can be treated as a safe surface. Arrange access that avoids standing on them, and treat any roof of unknown material the same way until its material is identified. A fall through a sheet is a fall from height, so the risk is not worth a quick look.

02How can I find out what my roof sheets are made of?

HSE says: "If the building was built or refurbished before 2000, assume that there is asbestos in it." That is the working assumption until a survey or a sample says otherwise. Sheets cannot be identified reliably by sight, so do not cut, drill or lift one to check. The identification comes first, and the written price for the work follows it.

03Does non-licensed asbestos work mean there are no rules?

No. Non-licensed describes a group of work, not an absence of requirements. HSE's example is asbestos cement roof sheeting "provided the material is carefully handled/removed without breaking up", and that proviso carries weight. The waste then needs a lockable skip, and the job needs a construction phase plan. Broken-up sheeting falls into the notifiable group, which brings further requirements, and the written price reflects the route.

04Can asbestos cement sheets go in an ordinary skip?

HSE's instruction is "Use a lockable skip for asbestos", with sheeting thrown over a standard skip ruled out as not good enough. The household exemption from the consignment note covers hazardous waste "(other than asbestos waste)", so asbestos waste is not covered by it. Ask who the registered carrier is before the job begins, and ask where the skip will stand, because a skip placed on the highway may need a licence of its own.

05Does weathering make asbestos cement sheets licensed work?

HSE's non-licensed group includes work with asbestos cement "which is weathered but not otherwise substantially damaged", so weathering alone does not change the group. Damage does: sheeting broken up by a fire or a flood moves into the notifiable group. Licensed work is a third group, covering insulating board work that is not short in duration, and it is carried out by contractors licensed for it. The roof is assessed before any group is chosen.

Get a written price for your roof

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing

Tell us about your roof

Call WhatsApp Written quote