The short answer
New tiles can go on old battens only when the battens are sound and set at the right spacing for the new tile. A different tile length or lap changes that spacing, and rotten, split or badly nailed battens are replaced. BS 5534 covers how slating and tiling is fixed.
What a batten does, and how it wears
A batten is a thin strip of timber nailed across the rafters over the underlay. Each course of tiles hangs from its batten by a nib on the back of the tile, and nails or clips add to that hold on the courses the specification calls for. The batten therefore carries the tiles and passes their load into the rafters.
Timber that has sat under a covering for a long time has had a hard life, and its condition varies a great deal from one roof to the next. Damp is the main threat. A cracked tile, a slipped slate or a worn underlay lets water onto a batten, and softened wood stops holding a nail. Old battens also carry rows of nail holes from the earlier covering, and each hole is a place where the wood can split when it is fixed again.
A check from the loft only shows the undersides. Once the covering is off, the top faces and the ends can be examined, which is where rot and splitting can show up. A batten that bends when pressed, crumbles at an end or has lost its nail grip is replaced.
Checking every batten matters more than checking a few, because a single weak lath beneath a course of tiles leaves that course badly supported.
The gauge has to suit the new tile
Gauge is the distance from one batten to the next, measured along the slope. It is not a free choice. It follows from the length of the tile and the lap, which is how far each course covers the one below. Change the tile and the gauge can change with it.
That is the heart of the old-batten question. Old battens were fixed at a gauge that suited the old tiles. Where the replacement is the same size and lap, the spacing may match. Where it is longer, shorter or laid to a different lap, the battens sit in the wrong places and have to be moved or replaced. The table sets out the cases.
| Situation | Old battens |
|---|---|
| Same tile, sound timber | May be refixed, with failed lengths replaced |
| Different tile length or lap | Spacing is reset, which means new battens |
| Rot, splits or soft ends | Replaced, whatever the tile |
| Underlay found failed | Battens lifted to renew it |
Spacing at the eaves and the ridge is worked out separately from the field of the roof, since the first and last courses have their own set-out. A survey of the roof shows how much of this applies.
Standards, cost and the decision
BS 5534:2014+A2:2018 is listed as current by BSI. Marley notes that installing to BS 5534 isn't required by law. The same maker adds that each roof's own fixing specification overrides the standard's baseline figures. Battens belong to that fixing system, so a lath that cannot hold its nails weakens the whole arrangement.
New battens add a little to the materials in a re-tile, but beside the tiles and the labour they are a small item, and refixing weak ones can cost more than replacing them. Whatever is found, the quote for the job is a single figure given after the survey, and the pitched roof costs guide covers what moves it.
- Soundness: no rot, splits, soft ends or lost nail grip.
- Section and spacing: set out to suit the chosen tile.
- Underlay beneath: whole, lapped and not perished.
- Fixings: nail type and pattern as the specification requires.
A whole-roof re-covering also meets Building Regulations: the Planning Portal's main page says that in most situations this work will need Building Regulations approval. The re-tiling and Building Regulations page gives the weight and area limits.
In practice the decision is simple. Look at the battens, match the gauge to the tile that has been chosen, and replace whatever fails either test.

