The short answer
Neither is cheaper as a rule: size, access and covering decide. Published figures cover different jobs, so they are not comparable directly. Which? Trusted Traders give £1,400 to £3,500 for felt on a single garage and £7,000 to £21,000 for replacing an average three-bedroom house's entire roof, both excluding VAT (November 2025).
Why one shape is not automatically cheaper
A roof price is built from area, access, covering, structure and whatever the survey turns up. The slope is only one input. A small flat roof over a garage and a large pitched roof over a house are different jobs, so the cheaper one is simply the smaller one.
Shape does change some of the arithmetic. A sloping roof has more surface than the footprint beneath it, so it needs more covering for the same floor area, and the work needs edge protection or scaffold. A flat roof is smaller in surface, but it has its own demands: the deck, the insulation, the falls and the waterproof layer all have to be right.
Comparing like with like would mean pricing the same building both ways, and none of the figures below does that. Your own roof needs its own survey and a written quote, since the same footprint can price very differently once the deck, the insulation and the access are known.
Access matters on both. Roof height, a tight garden or a frontage on the road can add cost whichever shape the roof has. We arrange the licence with our scaffolder when a scaffold has to sit on public ground, and the work around it then needs planning in the right order.
The sourced figures, side by side
Each row below is a separate source describing its own job. They are listed together for reference and never added up or averaged.
| Source and date | Job | Figure |
|---|---|---|
| Which?, Nov 2025 | Felt, single garage, 6m x 3m | £1,400 to £3,500 |
| Which?, Nov 2025 | EPDM with new boards, same garage | £1,950 to £4,000 |
| Which?, Nov 2025 | Whole roof, average three-bedroom house | £7,000 to £21,000 |
| MyJobQuote, 2026 | Flat roof replacement | £1,500 to £6,000 |
| HomeBuilding, Sept 2025 | Semi, 65m² roof, plain concrete tiles | may cost £10,000 to £15,000 |
The Which? figures come from a survey of 11 Which? Trusted Traders and exclude VAT. MyJobQuote prints no VAT basis, and describes its range as what flat roof replacement costs in 2026. HomeBuilding's line for the semi is that it "may cost between £10,000 and £15,000".
The garage rows and the house row do not describe the same building, so they say nothing about which shape is cheaper. Treat each as a reference point for its own kind of job. The pitched roof costs guide covers the pitched side in more detail.
What the price buys: lifespan and rules
A lower first price can come with a shorter life, and a longer-lived covering can come with a higher one, so lifespans belong beside costs. The two sources give different ranges for flat roofs. HomeBuilding gives EPDM 25-30 years, GRP 25-30 and felt 10-15, while Less says EPDM typically lasts 30 to 50 years, GRP 25 to 40 and torch-on felt 10 to 20, depending on quality and installation.
For pitched coverings, HomeBuilding gives approximate lifespans of 60-80 years for clay tiles and 40-50 years for plain concrete tiles. The how long roof tiles last guide sets the pitched figures out in full.
Rules touch both shapes. A full pitched re-cover affects more than 50% of the roof, which goes past the Planning Portal's limit, so it needs Building Regulations approval, and that sits inside the price whichever shape the roof has. A flat roof's replacement waterproof layer also brings insulation questions, so the build-up is settled at survey.
So the useful question is not which shape costs less. It is which covering and build-up suit your roof, and what the written price after a survey says for it. Photos sent on WhatsApp to 07880 284133 can help a first conversation, though a survey is still needed before anything is priced.

