The short answer
It depends on the particular slate and the particular tile, so the answer comes from product weights, not from the material name. The rule that matters is the change: a new covering 15 per cent or more heavier than the old one needs Building Regulations approval, and a structural engineer or surveyor should check the roof first.
What the 15 per cent rule measures
Weight is not a property of a material name. Slates come in different sizes and thicknesses, and roof tiles come in different types, so the weight of a covering is read from the maker's data for the exact product. A fair comparison sets two named products side by side, with their battens and fixings, and does not pit slate against tile as categories. Two slates from different quarries can differ from each other as much as a slate differs from a tile.
The rules look at the change instead. The Planning Portal's re-roofing guide puts approval in place wherever a new covering material adds to the weight of the roof covering by "15 per cent or more". Approved Document A, which deals with structure, treats a roof load "increased by more than 15%" as a significant change. The two sources word the line differently, so each is quoted exactly as it is printed and not merged into one.
The Planning Portal's main re-roofing page adds that, where the weight rises, you are advised to check with a structural engineer or surveyor before the work begins. A heavier covering is a structural question first and a roofing question second. The guide to slate roofs and Building Regulations covers the wider approval picture.
What a structural check looks at
A structural check asks whether the roof's timbers can carry the finished covering, its battens and the loads already acting on them. Rafters, purlins and wall plates are looked at for size, spacing and condition, along with signs of past movement such as a sagging ridge or a bowed slope. The check is made on the roof as it stands, because an older frame may have been altered, notched for services or weakened by damp over the years.
| Question | Where it is settled |
|---|---|
| Weight of the new covering | The maker's data for the named product |
| Weight of the old covering | The existing roof, as surveyed |
| Can the timbers carry it | A structural engineer or surveyor |
| Is approval needed | Building control, using the 15 per cent test |
Our part begins with looking over the roof ahead of any quote, and the price after it is one written total. That order means the structural question is answered before a figure is set, rather than being argued about halfway through the job when the old covering is already off and the rafters are in view.
Weight, fixings and the whole roof
Weight is one load among several. A slate roof carries its own covering, any snow that settles on it and the wind lifting at its edges, so the way the slates are held down counts as much as the slates themselves. BS 5534:2014+A2:2018 is the standard that covers slating and tiling, and it is a code of practice, not law: Marley says that installing to it "isn't required by law". Fixings are still specified against it, and the specification is worked out for each individual roof.
Natural and man-made slates are different products, each with its own technical data, so any swap between them is checked against the figures for the two named products and not against a general rule of thumb. The natural and man-made slate guide sets out how they differ in other ways, including how each is made.
The slate roofing page lists the kinds of work a survey covers. If you already know which product you have, or which one you are considering, send its name and a photograph of the roof on WhatsApp, 07880 284133, and the photo will be looked at.

