Does re-slating need Building Regulations approval?
Start with the size of the job, because the covering is not what decides. The Planning Portal's interactive guide sets two limits for skipping an application, and the job has to sit inside both. The first is "Less than 25 per cent of the total 'building envelope'", a count that takes in every wall, window, door and floor as well as the roof. The second is "Less than 50 per cent of the roof is affected." Inside those limits, the Portal says, an application is normally not needed.
Take a repair that swaps out a few cracked slates: one slope, a small patch, well inside both limits. A full re-slate sits on the far side of the line, since every slope is stripped and the 50 per cent roof limit is passed. Past that point the roof is mostly affected, which is where approval begins. For that kind of job the Portal's main re-roofing page is blunt: "In most situations, this work will need Building Regulations approval."
A trap lies in the 25 per cent figure. It belongs to the whole envelope, not to the roof, and the 50 per cent roof limit is a separate test. A summary that mentions only one of the two sends the reader to the wrong answer on a bigger job, so both are always read together.
| Job | Position | Source |
|---|---|---|
| A few slates replaced | Within both limits: no application normally needed | Planning Portal |
| A full re-slate | Over the 50 per cent roof limit: approval needed | Planning Portal |
| A heavier covering | Approval needed, structural check advised | Planning Portal |
| Chimney breast removed | Approval always applies | Planning Portal |
The weight trigger for a new covering
Weight is the second trigger. For "a new covering material which increases the weight of the roof covering by 15 per cent or more", the Planning Portal says approval is needed. Approved Document A phrases its own test as a roof loading "increased by more than 15%." The two sources differ by a hair, so a sentence should quote one of them and name it, never blend the two into a single round figure.
Before work starts on a heavier covering, the Portal says to check with a structural engineer or surveyor before the job begins. Timbers and walls were sized for the load they were built to take, and swapping the covering moves that load. The reliable way to compare is two data sheets in the same unit, old covering beside new, never a guess from the name of the material.
A separate trigger has nothing to do with weight. The Portal also asks for approval where a new covering would behave differently in a fire from the one it replaces. That makes each covering's data sheet worth reading for its fire classification. Our guide to natural and man-made slate compares the two families.
- the new covering's weight per square metre, taken from the maker's data sheet
- the old covering's weight, so the gap can be worked out
- whether the roof timbers have been checked by a structural engineer or surveyor
- whether the fire classification of the new covering matches the old
Who signs off the work
Two kinds of body can inspect the work: the council's own building control team, or a registered building control approver. Private firms doing this work are not new. What changed on 6 April 2024 is registration, with private businesses applying to the Building Safety Regulator before they can carry out building control in England and Wales.
The paperwork at the end depends on the route. Where the council is the inspector, the certificate is a completion certificate (regulation 17 of the Building Regulations 2010). Where a registered approver is, it is a final certificate (section 51 of the Building Act 1984). Each records that the work complies. Asking which route a job will take, and who will issue the certificate, is a fair question to put to any firm before a quote is accepted.
A Dunstable house falls under Central Bedfordshire Council, whose building control team can be reached on 0300 300 8635, a line for building control, not planning, enquiries. In Luton the council's building control service is on 01582 546607. If a slate job goes past the Portal's limits, we check the route with that council's building control before work starts.
A repair inside the limits does not normally need an application. The choice between patching and stripping a roof is covered in our guide to repairing or replacing a slate roof.
Part L and the energy figures
Part L of the Building Regulations deals with energy. The 2021 edition of Approved Document L, which applies in England, gives a renovated roof two numbers in Table 4.3: a threshold of 0.35 W/m²K and an improved target of 0.16 W/m²K. Renovate more than 50% of the roof surface and the document looks for the whole roof to be brought to the improved target, feasibility permitting.
Feasibility has a limit. If the upgrade cannot be done for technical or functional reasons, or cannot reach a "simple payback of 15 years or less", the upgrade stops at what is feasible inside a 15-year payback, as paragraph 4.13 describes.
| Item | Figure | Where it sits |
|---|---|---|
| Threshold | 0.35 W/m²K | Table 4.3, column (a) |
| Improved target | 0.16 W/m²K | Table 4.3, column (b) |
| Payback test | 15 years | Paragraph 4.13 |
The covering does not set the roof's U-value. The layers beneath it do, meaning insulation fitted between or over the rafters. That is why a re-slate and its insulation are one question, not two. The 2026 edition of Approved Document L applies from 24 March 2027 and renumbers the tables, so until then the 2021 numbers are the ones in force.
Planning and Class C
Planning is a separate regime from Building Regulations. A re-slate is judged under Class C of Schedule 2, Part 1 of the General Permitted Development Order, which covers "Any other alteration to the roof of a dwellinghouse". GOV.UK's technical guidance describes Class C as covering "other alterations to roofs such as re-roofing or the installation of roof lights/windows."
Class C carries limits of its own. The alteration may not protrude more than 0.15 metres beyond the plane of the slope of the original roof, and may not leave its highest part above the highest part of the original roof. Chimneys, flues and soil and vent pipes are excluded from Class C, so work on those is judged on its own terms.
A roof window on a side slope has a further condition. It must be obscure-glazed, and non-opening unless the parts of the window which can be opened are more than 1.7 metres above the floor of the room in which the window is installed. The 1.7 metre figure relaxes only the second condition, never the first.
For flat owners the picture differs. A building made up of flats is not a dwellinghouse under the order, which leaves its occupiers without householder rights, and roof questions on a flat start with the council.
Conservation areas and listed homes
A conservation area does not remove Class C. Conservation areas count as article 2(3) land, and article 2(3) land takes away Class B, the rights for roof enlargements such as dormers, so a dormer there needs planning permission. GOV.UK's guidance gives Class C no article 2(3) exclusion, so the right to re-roof remains.
What can change a re-slate is an Article 4 direction. GOV.UK explains that a direction lets the Secretary of State or the local planning authority withdraw specified permitted development rights across a defined area. The question to put to the council is whether a direction applies to the street in question, before any slates come off.
A listed home keeps Classes B and C, because neither carries a listed exclusion. Separately, listed building consent applies to works "in any manner which would affect its character as a building of special architectural or historic interest". Whether a change of slate, size or fixing touches character is a question for the council ahead of the work, and the answer for one listed house does not carry over to the next.
| Setting | Re-roofing (Class C) | Also check |
|---|---|---|
| Conservation area | Not removed | Article 4 direction; dormers need permission |
| Listed home | Not removed | Listed building consent |
| Flat | No householder rights | The council |
Standards for fixing and pitch
How slate is fixed rests on standards as well as regulations. The live edition of BS 5534, the slating and tiling code for pitched roofs, is BS 5534:2014+A2:2018. Marley notes that fitting to BS 5534 "isn't required by law". Since the 2015 amendments, mortar "could no longer be relied upon as the only means of securing the roof covering". For ridge, hip and verge fixed dry, with no mortar bed, the standard is BS 8612:2018, which BSI lists as current.
Pitch carries conditions. Cupa, a slate maker, reports that BS 5534 indicates a 20 degree minimum for natural slate, on stated terms: moderate exposure, a 500 mm slate and a 115 mm overlap. Below 25 degrees Cupa excludes hook fixings altogether. A lower pitch changes the slate, the overlap or the fixing. Our guide to the minimum pitch for slate goes through these conditions in turn.
Exposure is handled by calculation, not by a rule of thumb. Marley's guidance says the BS 5534 minimums "will always be superseded by the generation of a Fixing Specification, which is site specific". Marley adds that ridge or hip tiles are always fixed mechanically, sized to the calculated wind uplift force. Fixings are therefore worked out for the site's exposure, and a roof that meets the pitch minimum is not automatically fixed correctly.

