Call 01582 935272

Slate roofing

Does a slate roof need underlay?

A slate roof laid to modern practice has underlay beneath the battens as a second layer of protection. The type chosen affects how the roof space is ventilated.

Get a written quote

Call 01582 935272WhatsApp us

Tall brick chimney stacks with clay pots rising from the slate roofs of a Victorian terrace
PicturedTall brick chimney stacks with clay pots rising from the slate roofs of a Victorian terrace.

The short answer

Yes, modern slating is laid over an underlay fixed to the rafters, with battens above it and the slates on those. The underlay catches wind-blown rain and condensation that the slates let past. The type matters: high-resistance and low-resistance underlays call for different ventilation in a cold roof.

A roof drawing with its parts named: daylight, damp stain, purlin, loft hatchDaylightDamp stainPurlinLoft hatch

What underlay does under slates

From the rafters upwards, a pitched slate roof is built in layers. The underlay is laid over the rafters, battens are fixed through it, and the slates are hung from the battens. Slates shed water by overlap, but a gap in a lap, a cracked slate or driven rain can let some past, and the underlay is the second line that carries it down to the gutter. Without it, the battens and the slates are the only barrier, and that leaves little margin when wind drives rain upward under a lap.

It also deals with moisture from inside. Warm, damp air from the house can reach the cold side of the roof, where it may condense on cold surfaces, and the underlay and the ventilation around it are part of how that is managed. The 2021 edition of BS 5250, the standard on managing moisture in buildings, is the one in force.

The slates themselves are fixed under BS 5534:2014+A2:2018. Marley says installing to BS 5534 "isn't required by law", yet a roof built to it carries known fixing and lap details. The layers work together, so a good underlay under poor slating, or the other way round, leaves a weak point somewhere in the roof, and that weak point is what the survey looks for.

Underlay resistance and what it means for air

Underlays are grouped by how freely water vapour passes through them. An HR underlay (high resistance) stops vapour passing, so air in the roof space needs another route out. A low-resistance underlay, written LR, lets more vapour through. Which of the two is chosen sets what ventilation the roof needs, and it is a decision taken with the covering and the ceiling in mind.

Underlay type and ventilation, as Marley gives it
Roof buildVentilation named
Cold roof, HR underlay, pitch of 15° or less25 mm along the eaves
Cold roof, HR underlay, pitch above 15°10 mm along the eaves
LR underlay, well-sealed ceiling, air-permeable covering3 mm normal eaves construction, with UKAS third-party certification

Marley's wording for the last row is that "fortuitous ventilation at the eaves via normal eaves construction (3mm) is all that is required, provided the requirements of UKAS Third Party certification are fully met." The first two rows apply to a cold roof with HR underlay. Every condition in a row has to be met together, which is why the underlay, the ceiling and the covering are all checked against the data for the exact products before a specification is settled.

Older slate roofs and what a survey checks

Not every slate roof was built to today's practice. An older roof may have been laid with no underlay at all, or with a felt that has since dried out, torn or slipped. Such a roof can have kept the rain out for years because the slates were sound, and the underlay's absence only shows when slates slip or a gap opens. Torn or slipped felt can sit unseen for years above a sound-looking ceiling.

When an old covering is lifted for re-slating or repair, the opportunity to fit proper underlay arrives with it. The rafters are visible, battens can be renewed where they have rotted, and the ventilation is set to suit the underlay chosen. The guide to slate roofs and Building Regulations explains where approval applies to the work.

Looking over the roof includes the underlay wherever it shows, at the eaves and from inside the loft, and the signs of trouble beneath the slates. Condensation on the rafters, daylight between laps, stained boards and a damp smell can all point to a failed underlay or poor ventilation. Our slate roofing page describes the work, and a photograph sent to 07880 284133 on WhatsApp is a first step toward a view.

Slate roof underlay, answered

01Can slates be laid directly onto battens with no underlay?

On an older roof they may have been, and some still are in place. A roof built to current practice is laid over an underlay. Without one, nothing catches rain that is driven past a lap or a cracked slate, and nothing manages condensation under the slates. Ask for the underlay to be named on any quote, and for it to be fitted. A roofer who lifts a few slates can confirm what is there.

02What does HR underlay stand for and why does it matter?

HR means high resistance. In a cold roof with that type of underlay, the eaves must be ventilated along their length: Marley gives 25 mm at a pitch of 15° or less and 10 mm above 15°. An LR underlay, which stands for low resistance, with a well-sealed ceiling can rely on normal eaves construction if its certification requirements are met.

03Does underlay need replacing when slates are renewed?

Where the covering comes off, the underlay beneath is in plain view, and an old, torn or perished one is replaced at that stage. Leaving it in place under a new covering would put a weak layer beneath fresh slate. Whether yours is sound is a question for the survey, since it can be hard to judge from below the rafters.

04Is eaves ventilation needed with a slate roof?

It depends on the roof build and the underlay, as Marley's figures show. Cold roofs with a high-resistance underlay need a continuous gap along the eaves. Other builds rely on normal eaves construction if certification conditions are met. Call 01582 935272 to talk through the roof, since the right answer comes from the roof as it is built, not from a general rule.

Get a written price for your roof

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing

Tell us about your roof

Call WhatsApp Written quote