01 A heavier covering
A new covering changes the load on the rafters, and the rules watch for that. The Planning Portal lists as a trigger a new covering material that "increases the weight of the roof covering by 15 per cent or more", and for weight it advises seeking a structural engineer's or surveyor's view before work begins. Approved Document A puts it this way: "A significant change in roof loading is when the loading upon the roof is increased by more than 15%." Neither source ranks one material above another for weight, and nor do we.
From inside the loft you can see whether the rafters already sag between their supports, whether the ridge dips, or whether old repairs have been nailed beside cracked timbers. Photograph anything that looks bent before a new covering is discussed, and a torch held along the rafter shows a bow better than the naked eye does. The survey looks at the covering on the roof now, so a replacement is judged against the real roof, never against a guess based on the neighbours' houses.

