The short answer
Fibre cement slate is a man-made roofing slate, formed from cement reinforced with fibres and pressed or cut into slate-shaped tiles. It is laid in overlapping courses like natural slate. Older fibre cement products can contain asbestos, so a roof built or refurbished before 2000 is checked before anyone cuts or drills it.
What fibre cement slate is made from
Fibre cement slate is a manufactured covering. A mix of cement and reinforcing fibres is formed into thin, flat sheets, cut to the size and shape of a slate and finished in a grey or dark colour so that it reads as slate from the pavement. It is one of the man-made slates sold as an alternative to quarried stone, and it sits within the wider slate roofing field alongside natural products.
The way it is laid follows natural slate. The units hang on battens in overlapping courses, each row covering the heads of the row below, and nails or clips hold them. The overlap, called the headlap, is what keeps water out, which is covered in the answer on headlap on a slate roof.
Where fibre cement differs from natural slate is in how it is made, not how it is hung. Natural slate is split from rock in a quarry, so every piece has its own thickness and surface. A manufactured unit is produced to a pattern, which is why a fibre cement roof can look more uniform. How the two compare as a choice for a new roof is set out in natural against man-made slate.
Why the age of the product counts
Fibre cement is not one product with one history. Some older fibre cement sheets and slates may have contained asbestos fibres as their reinforcement, while products sold now are made without it. A roof laid decades ago can therefore be made of something very different from a roof laid recently, even though both look alike from the ground.
HSE gives a plain rule for buildings of that age: "If the building was built or refurbished before 2000, assume that there is asbestos in it." HSE also states that "AC roofs are always fragile". On a building of that age, a cement slate roof is handled with the same caution until a test has settled what it is made of.
- Do not drill, cut, scrub or jet wash a roof that may contain asbestos.
- Do not break a slate or sheet to see what is inside it.
- Do not stand on an old fibre cement roof, because it can crack and drop a person through.
Whether a particular roof contains asbestos is a question for a test and not for a guess made from the garden. HSE separates carefully removed asbestos cement, which is non-licensed work, from material that is broken up or in poor condition, which is notifiable. A surveyor will say which situation applies to a given roof.
Repairing, replacing and choosing fibre cement
A fibre cement slate roof is repaired in much the same way as a natural slate roof. Broken units are replaced, slipped ones are refixed, and the ridge and valleys are checked for damage. Repairs to a modern product use matching modern slates, so the question for an older roof is whether the existing units are free of asbestos before any work begins.
Fibre cement and natural slate are different products, and neither material is promised to last for a stated number of years. The lifespan approximations for natural slate, from HomeBuilding, are discussed in how long a slate roof lasts; fibre cement is not covered by those figures, so no number is offered for it here.
The choice between natural and man-made slate comes down to the building, its planning status and the budget. A listed building or a house in a conservation area may call for natural slate, and the council can say whether that applies. Our survey looks at the roof, the pitch and the fixings, and the price we give afterwards is one written figure covering the whole job. If you are unsure what your roof is made of, a clear photograph sent by WhatsApp to 07880 284133 gets the question started.

