The short answer
Slate hooks are metal fixings that hold a slate by its lower edge, instead of a nail driven through its head. Each hook is nailed to a batten and curls round the slate beneath. Cupa says they should not go on any pitch below 25 degrees, so hooks suit steeper roofs only.
How a hook holds a slate
A traditional slate roof is fixed with nails. Each slate has a hole near its head, a nail goes through the hole into the batten, and the course above covers the nail so that no fixing is exposed. That is called head nailing, and it is the method described on the main slate roofing page.
Hook fixing works from the other end. A hook is a bent metal clip, formed from stainless steel or another corrosion-resistant metal, fixed to the batten, which then curls up and over the lower edge of the slate. The slate hangs in the hook instead of on a nail passing through its own body. Because no hole is drilled in the slate, the stone is not weakened at that point.
Hooks are sometimes used on roofs where the slates are thin, brittle or irregular and a nail hole could crack them. They can also be used to refix slates on an older roof where the original nail fixings have given way, since the hook grips the slate edge and takes weight off a corroded nail. The cause of that failure is described in the answer on nail fatigue on a slate roof.
Where hooks are not suitable
A nail fixing and a hook fixing do not carry the load in the same way, and the pitch of the roof changes the picture. On a shallow slope the slates sit closer to flat, water is slower to leave, and wind can lift an edge more easily. Cupa, a slate maker, gives a floor for hooks of 25 degrees: its advice is to keep them off any slope shallower than that.
That figure is a different limit from the one that applies to slate roofing in general. For natural slate, Cupa reports that BS 5534 indicates a minimum pitch of 20 degrees at moderate exposure, using a slate 500 mm long and a 115 mm overlap. Hooks need a roof at least 5 degrees steeper than that. The full pitch question is covered in the minimum pitch for slate.
- Below 25 degrees: nail fixing is the route, and a hook is ruled out on Cupa's advice.
- From 25 degrees up: hooks can be an option, subject to the slate, the batten and the exposure of the site.
- On any roof: the fixings are worked out to suit how exposed the particular site is, in a specification written for that building.
The pitch of an existing roof is measured at the survey. It is not worth guessing from the ground, because a roof that looks steep can turn out to be shallower than it seems.
Hooks, nails and the repair question
Neither fixing is better in every situation. A nailed roof is the traditional form and is well understood. A hooked roof avoids the hole in the slate but depends on the hook, the batten and the slate edge all staying sound. A hook that has rusted, or a batten that has softened, lets the slate drop in much the same way that a failed nail does.
For a small repair, a roofer may use a tingle, a hidden strip that holds a single replacement slate, rather than a hook. That is explained in what a tingle is on a slate roof. Where a whole slope needs refixing, the choice between nails and hooks is made once the pitch, the slate thickness and the batten condition are known.
The standard that covers slating and tiling is BS 5534:2014+A2:2018, and Marley points out that installing to it "isn't required by law". The detail of a particular job is settled in its own specification. A survey is where the pitch and the existing fixings are checked, and what we quote afterwards is a single figure set down in writing.

