The short answer
Nail fatigue is the loss of grip in the nails that hold slates to their battens, caused by corrosion or by the nail wearing through the slate around it. The slates then slip down their courses or drop out. A few loose slates can be repaired, but a slope full of them points to failing fixings.
What nail fatigue means for slates
On a traditional roof, each slate hangs from nails. Each nail passes through a hole near the head of the slate and into the batten behind, and the slates in the course above cover it. The slate does not rest on the roof; it hangs from those two small points. The fixing is out of sight and out of mind for decades, and that is also why a failure can come as a surprise.
Nail fatigue is what happens when those fixings stop doing their job. A nail can corrode, so that its shank thins and eventually snaps or no longer grips. A nail hole in the slate can also wear oversize, so that the nail head pulls through the stone. Either way the slate loses its hold on the batten, and gravity does the rest: it slides down until its tail hangs below the line of the course, or it drops out altogether.
The term describes the fixings, not the slates. A slate that is cracked by a branch is a different problem. When a slate slides because its nail has given up, that says something about the nail, and about its neighbours of the same age and make that are still in place. The wider slate roofing page, slate roofing, describes how the full covering is built.
Signs your fixings are going
Loose slates are the visible result, and some of them can be seen from the garden or pavement. Others show up only inside the house, in a heap of broken slate in the gutter, or in a scatter of fragments on a path or a lower roof after a windy night.
- Slates that have slid down so that their lower edges sit below their neighbours in the row.
- Gaps in the pattern where a slate has dropped out, with the batten visible.
- Pieces of slate on the ground, on a flat roof below, or in the gutter.
- Rust-coloured stains running down the face of slates, which can mean nails are corroding beneath.
- Daylight or staining in the loft, along the line of a slope.
Any one of these can have another cause. One slipped slate can be a one-time event, and a stain can come from a gutter. What counts is the pattern: slipped slates spread across a whole slope, or turning up again after a repair, suggest the nails across that slope are tired. The page on why slates slip lists the other causes to rule out first.
What happens next on a roof with tired nails
Where only a handful of slates have gone and the rest are firm, a repair can be enough, and it is a sensible first thought. Each lost slate is replaced and held with a small hidden strip, known as a tingle, which is described in what a tingle is on a slate roof. That is a patch, and it does not make the surrounding nails any younger.
Where the slipping is spread across a slope, a survey looks at the nails themselves. A slate can be lifted carefully to see the state of the nail and the batten behind. If the fixings are corroded across the slope, the sound answer is to strip and relay it: slates in good condition are set aside, the battens are checked, and the slates go back on with new fixings. The choice between a series of repairs and relaying is set out in repair or replace a slate roof.
Until someone has looked at it, treat the roof as unsafe to walk on. A slate that has lost its nail can slide further when it is stepped on, and a fall from a roof does more harm than a leak ever will. Standing on the ground, you can learn a good deal with binoculars: look along each course for a slate that sits lower than the rest, and for a dark gap where one has dropped out. Note which slope it is and how many you can count, so that the picture you send is clear and the pattern is plain to see.

